2/23/2008

The Songwriters Association of Canada wants a Settlement

This is an outrage!
The [SAC] which is funded by the government of Canada though the Canada music fund and Canadian Heritage would have the government raise the money by applying a $5 a month tax on every internet and wireless account in Canada...
At five dollars per month, the proposed tax could conceivably raise over $125 million dollars a month or $1.5 billion dollars annually...
The amount being demanded is staggering when you consider that $1.5 billion annually dwarfs the actual financial impact of music downloading. According to the CRIA, total Canadian CD sales fell from about $700 in 1999 to $560 million in 2004. If we make the assumption that all of that decline is attributable to music downloading (which many critics dispute) the total economic damage is under $150 million annually or less than 10% of what SAC is asking!

But here is the kicker.
...the group is also proposing the federal government make an amendment to the Copyright Act that would make it legal for Canadians to download and share any music file regardless of its origin.
In simple terms the group is lobbying the government to abolish illegal file sharing in exchange for its members receiving $1.5 billion dollars in tax revenues.

What this means is that the Songwriters Association of Canada wants to settle. They want the government to give them $1.5billion a year in order to not prosecute anyone who downloads music. Essentially what they are saying is "Give us enough money and we will agree that downloading music ought to be legal."
The SAC, the CRIA and the RIAA are nothing short of thugs. The recording industry produces mountains of garbage every year that they pretend is music. Hollywood and all its relevant unions are just as bad. Significantly more bad movies are made than good. Instead of recognizing the staggering lack of talent in the entertainment "industry," these people have the unmitigated gall to demand monetary compensation from the average individual. They arm wrestle governments into passing punitive laws against copyright infringement, all the while pretending that they do so for the benefit of their artists rather than for their own monetary gain. They pump out commercials which erroneously declare "Piracy is stealing" in order to befuddle the general population who have absolutely no idea that copyright infringement is not stealing and is treated very differently under then law than theft is.
Carefully consider what the SAC's logic must be in order to arrive at their $5 per month levy.
1. Illegal downloading caused a drop in profits.
2. "Everyone" downloads illegally.
3. Therefore, force everyone to compensate us for our losses times 10 regardless of whether or not number 1 or 2 is true, which by the way they aren't. In fact, both are demonstrably false!
If, like me, you are appalled by the notion ought to be able to demand such a levy, then I recommend you contact Canadian Heritage at 1 866-811-0055 or by email at cmf-music@pch.gc.ca. These people already get enough of our tax money. They don't deserve so much as another dime! If they are in any way broke (and they aren't) then they can start producing higher quality material!
And while you're at it, contact your MP and protest the Digital Millennium Copyright Act.

4 comments:

spike said...

so people like myself who don't download music are going to get taxed again if this agreement goes through.

Mé said...

Sounds very Caledonianish.

I don't download music. Why should I have to pay $5? I can't wait for the $5 porn tax.

Anonymous said...

Next the CRTC will levee a Monthly Fee for every TV to help support the NHL in canada because you just might was a game one night and the Players should be compensated for their talent .

We already get screwed by the CBC when part of out paycheck goes to fund it and produce intolerant bigotted tripe like Little Mosque on the Prairie where all the Christians are idiots and need to be rescued by the Hijab wearing Muslims who choose to obey the men and keep it on or face a Honour killing .

Oh wait....that episode is still in the can and may never get aired because even though 99% of the current Terrorists are Muslims, not all muslims are Terrorists and it's Racist to show Muslims in a negative light since not one of them are in a Canadian jail or unemployed and maybe on Welfare .

Most of the Canadian Artists seem to draw a Unemployment check
more often the producing something of value .

Swift said...

Let's not be too hasty in completely rejecting this proposal. Five dollars a month for the music library of your dreams is not completely outrageous. If you can't find a lot of music that you like that has already been recorded then you are one of the very few that just don't like any music. CD sales under this proposal would vanish, so that the amount of money would replace all the current sales. Obviously the song writers have suggested a rate that is more than they would accept as reasonable, so the actual charge would be less than $5 a month.

As a bonus, with unlimited downloads, the royalties per copy will plummet, forcing the record companies to actually produce music that most people like. Other royalty streams, such as commercial and internet radio, could be eliminated. The more I think about this, the more I like it. If this goes through, I'm going to be buying a gazillion meg hard drive and start downloading.

Listed on BlogsCanada Blogarama - The Blog Directory Powered by Blogger FeedBurner Blogging Tories
Southern Ontario Conservatives